Consumer Sentiment Plunges to Near-Record Lows as Tariffs Bite and Jobs Fears Mount
Consumer confidence collapsed to 55.1 in September, marking the seventh-lowest reading since record-keeping began in 1952, as Americans confront a toxic combination of persistent inflation, tariff-induced price shocks, and mounting unemployment fears.
The University of Michigan’s closely watched sentiment index fell 5% from August, confirming that economic pessimism has returned to levels rarely seen outside major recessions. The deterioration spans demographics, with particularly sharp declines among lower and middle-income households who bear the brunt of rising prices.
Tariffs Dominate Consumer Concerns
Trade policy has emerged as a dominant source of anxiety for American households. Approximately 60% of consumers spontaneously mentioned tariffs during survey interviews, maintaining elevated levels since President Trump announced new levies on trucks, furniture, and pharmaceuticals.
“Consumers continue to note multiple vulnerabilities in the economy, with rising risks to business conditions, labor markets, and inflation,” said Joanne Hsu, director of the University of Michigan’s Surveys of Consumers. Lower-income households face particular strain from tariffs, which function as a regressive tax that disproportionately impacts those least able to absorb higher prices.
Wealth Divide Shapes Sentiment
A striking divergence has emerged between Americans with substantial stock holdings and those without. Sentiment for consumers with larger stock holdings held steady, buoyed by record equity market levels, while those with smaller or no holdings experienced significant declines.
“With the market at record highs, despite the last few days, I definitely think it makes people feel comfortable about their savings,” noted one analyst. This wealth effect creates two distinct consumer realities: affluent Americans insulated by portfolio gains and working-class households squeezed between stagnant wages and rising costs.
Personal Financial Outlook Darkens
The deterioration extends beyond abstract economic concerns to hit consumers’ personal financial expectations. Nearly 70% of consumers expect inflation to exceed income gains in the year ahead, up from less than 60% a year ago, suggesting eroding confidence in real purchasing power.
Current views of personal finances have fallen about 13% since the beginning of 2025. A record 44% of consumers spontaneously mentioned that high prices are eroding their personal finances, the highest reading since November 2024. These trends signal that robust consumer spending, which has supported economic growth despite poor sentiment readings, may finally face pressure.
Job Loss Fears Accelerate
Labor market anxieties compound inflation worries. Consumers’ expected probability of personal job loss grew sharply throughout 2025 and ticked up in September to its highest reading since March, reflecting genuine concern about employment security.
The timing proves particularly worrisome given the Federal Reserve’s recent rate cut justified partly by labor market weakness. Consumers appear to perceive employment risks that extend beyond official statistics, suggesting potential trouble ahead for spending patterns.
Inflation Expectations Remain Elevated
While year-ahead inflation expectations held steady at 4.7%, long-run inflation expectations rose for a second straight month to 3.7%, well above the Federal Reserve’s 2% target. The persistence of elevated inflation expectations risks becoming self-fulfilling as consumers adjust behavior accordingly.
Oxford Economics analysts warn that tariffs and fiscal policy changes will “widen the bifurcation of American consumers,” with low-income households facing the steepest challenges. Unlike wealthier Americans who benefit from equity gains, these households confront the full force of tariff-induced price increases without offsetting wealth effects.
Spending Paradox Persists
Despite dismal sentiment readings, Americans continue spending at robust levels, creating what economists call the “sentiment-spending paradox.” This disconnect raises questions about sentiment surveys’ predictive value and the sustainability of current consumption patterns.
Historical context proves sobering. The current reading sits at the 1st percentile of all monthly data points since 1978, below levels recorded at the start of every recession during that period. Whether spending can remain resilient amid such pervasive pessimism remains an open question with significant implications for economic growth ahead.